Google WiFi vs Nest vs Orbi vs Eero vs Velop

Best Mesh WiFi

Home WiFi systems don’t flash off impressive features or immersive experiences like other tech does. However, it is the backbone of the modern-day world with huge importance in the household. As media quality improves and data volume increases, the need for the fastest, most reliable, most secure and most response WiFi system grows. From your laptop to your Amazon Echo, having the latest and best WiFi technology can give you a better user experience across the whole of your home. This article will compare the best mesh wifi routers and weigh up Google WiFi vs Orbi vs Eero vs Velop.

Google Nest WiFi Router 3 Pack (2nd Generation) – 4x4 AC2200 Mesh Wi-Fi Routers with 6600 Sq Ft Coverage
  • Nest wifi is a scalable and flexible wi-fi system. These nest wifi devices work together...
  • One WiFi router plugs into your internet provider’s modem to create your Wi-Fi network....
  • Nest WiFi routers are strong enough to handle up to 200 connected devices, and fast enough...

Comparison Table

ModelGoogle WiFiNest WiFiEeroOrbiVelop
Designgoogle wifiGoogle Nest WiFi 3 packeeroNetgear orbivelop
Wireless
Specs
-AC1200 2×2 Wave 2 Wi-Fi
-Expandable mesh Wifi
-Simultaneous dual-band Wifi (2.4 GHz/5 GHz)
-Supporting IEEE 802.11a/b/g/n/ac
-Bluetooth® Smart Ready
-AC2200 MU-MIMO Wi-Fi
4x4 (5 GHz)
2x2 (2.4 GHz)
-Simultaneous dual-band (2.4 GHz/5 GHz) Wi-Fi
-supporting IEEE 802.11a/b/g/n/ac
-Tri-band WiFi
2.4GHz, 5.2GHz, and 5.8GHz
-wireless2x2 MU-MIMO
-IEEE 802.11a/b/g/n/ac
-802.11ac/TTri-band WiFi technology
-MU-MIMO
-4X4 (1.7Gbps) dedicated backhaul
-6 high-performance antennas
-Tri-Band AC2200 (867 + 867 + 400 Mbps)‡
-MU-MIMO
-256 QAM
-Simultaneous Tri-Band
(2.4Ghz + 5GHz + 5GHz)
Beamforming
Ports2 Gigabit2 GigabitTwo auto-sensing
Gigabit ports for WAN
and/or LAN connectivity
Router – 1 WAN & 3LAN
Satellite – 4 WAN
USB 2.0, power
2x WAN/LAN auto-sensing
Gigabit Ethernet ports
Ram512 MB1 GB512 MB512 MB512 MB RAM
Flash Storage4 GB4 GB4 GB4 GB4 GB
ProcessorQuad-core ARM 710MHzQuad-core 64-bit ARM CPU 1.4 GHzQuad-core ARM 700MHzQuad-core ARM 710MHzQuad-core ARM 716MHz
Smart Speaker
Bottom LineGood Customer
Support
All Round BestSolid SpeedsGood for
Gaming
Good Long
Distance
Performance
AvailabilityCheck PriceCheck PriceCheck PriceCheck PriceCheck Price

Google WiFi

google wifi
Google WiFi

The worlds leading tech giant is dipping its toes in many markets at the moment. The Google WiFi mesh system was released at the end of 2016 and is their only Wifi router network available. The routers are available in a pack of either one, two or three modules. We all know that Google produces the most impressive hardware and software in the world. It is no surprise that their Google WiFi system is one of the best. Whether you are team Google, Apple or Amazon, the specs and performance of the Google WiFi system can’t be denied. A strong sense of simplicity with high performance is the message from these devices, a contrasting and competing set of characteristics which make it the device it is.


Design & Setup

The design is a particularly minimal white with a small matted “G” on the top to label its maker. There is a horizontal ring around the edge which has a soft blue light to indicate function.  Each WiFi point two Gigabit Ethernet ports and a power supply. The Google WiFi system has the easiest setup of any of the mesh routers on the market. The Google WiFi App hosts the wizard setup and simply requires you to scan the QR codes of any of your WiFi points. Set your network username and password then you are good to go. The dimensions are of each node is as follows:

  • Diameter: 106.1 mm (4.1 in)
  • Height: 68.7 mm (2.7 in)
  • Weight: 340g

google wifi app


Specs

Wireless

  • AC1200 2×2 Wave 2 Wi-Fi
  • Expandable mesh Wifi
  • Simultaneous dual-band Wifi (2.4 GHz/5 GHz) supporting IEEE 802.11a/b/g/n/ac
  • TX Beamforming
  • Bluetooth® Smart Ready

Ports

  • Two Gigabit Ethernet ports per Wifi point

Memory

  • 512 MB RAM
  • 4 GB eMMC flash storage

Processor

  • Quad-core ARM CPU – each core up to 710 MHz

Power

  • 15 Watt Power Adapter

Google WiFi App

The Google WiFi app provides a range of features that go beyond the setup. It is a control point that allows you to monitor your WiFi points and live coverage. There are a few very useful features that allow you to more precisely tweak your WiFi system:

  • Prioritize devices speed
  • Pause kids devices
  • Live bandwidth usage
  • Create a separate network for guest
  • Bandwidth speed test
  • Add other administrators to control the network

The Google WiFi app is undoubtedly the most impressive as a control panel for a mesh network at the moment. Again, this strongly backs up the sense of all-rounded quality you get from the expertize of Googles software engineering. Most router manufacturers are hardware-driven at their core, so it will lag in this area relative to the tech giants.


Coverage & Performance

With one Wifi Point, you can cover up to 85 square meters, two gets you anywhere from 85-170 square meres whilst three is appropriate for those who need to cover 170-420 square meters. You can use as any WiFi points as you want, but you will rarely need more than six. Google WiFi does not have the most cutting-edge hardware and eye-opening speeds. It does, however, offer one of the most reliable speeds over the whole mesh network. Over a Local Network (LAN), you can expect to get around 450 – 500Mbps speed. With a 100Mbps service from an ISP, many users have reported speeds maximizing or even exceeding this (up to 100Mbp). Google WiFi can maintain speeds within 100 ft fairly decently, but this can drop off beyond this.

Google WiFi system, 3-Pack - Router Replacement for Whole Home Coverage (NLS-1304-25),White
  • A new type of connected system for seamless WiFi coverage throughout your home, helping...
  • Replaces your current router, and works your modem and internet service. It’s compatible...
  • A single WiFi point covers up to 1,500 square feet, a set of three covers homes up to...

Google Nest WiFi

Google Nest WiFi 3 pack
Google Nest WiFi

Google has upped its mesh wifi game by releasing the Google Nest WiFi at the end of 2019. Taking on the Nest Labs branding, who is owned by Google, this Mesh WiFi system is a considerable upgrade from the original. In addition to being a WiFi router, each mesh unit also has a smart speaker and Google Assistant support. With a 360 degree speaker and a microphone, each Nest WiFi unit is effectively a Google Home Mini as well. Using the WiFi it provides, it can stream music, answer your questions, make calls and much more. In addition to these extra features, the router itself is quite a bit better than the original as it delivers faster speeds being an AC2200 router. Google claims it can have up to 100 devices operating on the network at one time. We compare the Nest WiFi vs Google WiFi in more detail in another article.

Design & Setup

The design of the Google Nest WiFi is a little more aesthetic than the original version. Rather than being a little hard-edged, it is a smooth dome shape but still following the minimalistic styling Google goes for. It is also slightly heavier and larger. Another subtle yet good improvement is the branded Google “G” on the top is imprinted rather than printed. The dimensions of each Google Nest unit is as follows:

  • Diameter: 110 mm (4.33 inches)
  • Height: 90.4 mm (3.55 inches)
  • Weight: 380 g

As this mesh wifi is just an upgrade from Google WiFi, the setup process has been designed to be simple. The process involves downloading the Google Home app, running through the configuration, plugging your routers in and setting up new devices using the QR code scanning system.

Specs

Wireless

  • AC2200 MU-MIMO Wi-Fi
  • 4×4 (5 GHz)
  • 2×2 (2.4 GHz)
  • IEEE 802.15.4 Thread (2.4 GHz)
  • TX Beamforming
  • Bluetooth® Low Energy

Ports

  • Dual Gigabit Ethernet ports
  • Barrel jack power

Memory

  • 1 GB RAM
  • 4 GB flash

Processor

  • Quad-core 64-bit ARM CPU 1.4 GHz

Power

  • 15 Watt Power Adapter

Google Home App

One difference with the newer Google Home Nest is that it is setup and controlled using the Google Home app, rather than the Google WiFi app. This is because Google are pushing to get all of their smart home devices under one system. Most of the features and controls are the same, such as prioritizing bandwidth, creating a guest network and parental controls. However, a few more advanced settings such as managing DNS and LAN settings have to be done in the Google WiFi app. If you select them in the Home app you will be redirected to change them.

Coverage & Performance

The Google Nest WiFi is considerably faster and wider-reaching than the previous generation. Each unit covers 2200 square feet whilst the original covers 1500 square feet. This could be the difference between having to buy one or two units if the size of your home sits between these two. The speed of the Google Nest WiFi is quite a bit better too, especially at 5 GHz frequencies where the maximum speed is 1733 Mbps compared to 867 Mbps. However, this may not be relevant if your paid internet service isn’t that speedy. Many tests of the speed at different ranges has found that the Nest WiFi router is generally just under twice as fast as the Google WiFi, which makes sense given its an AC2200 rather than  AC1200.

Google Nest WiFi Router 3 Pack (2nd Generation) – 4x4 AC2200 Mesh Wi-Fi Routers with 6600 Sq Ft Coverage
  • Nest wifi is a scalable and flexible wi-fi system. These nest wifi devices work together...
  • One WiFi router plugs into your internet provider’s modem to create your Wi-Fi network....
  • Nest WiFi routers are strong enough to handle up to 200 connected devices, and fast enough...


Netgear Orbi

Netgear orbi
Netgear Orbi

Netgear is one of the most established WiFi router manufacturers and a prominent figure in the tech industry. They have much expertise in not just wireless routers but also wireless cameras as seen in their Arlo cameras. When it came to producing their mesh wifi system, they have successfully applied their wireless capabilities in order to produce a reliable product. Where Orbi sticks out is the impressive hardware specs and very fast speeds. This mesh network is different from the Google WiFi in that it has a main router with accompanying Orbi Satellites. It is the satellites that provide the mesh function, which effectively achieves the same goal but through very slightly different means.


Design & Setup

The Orbi Satellite is a minimal design white with a blue light ring, although it is on the top of the device. It’s a relatively long and thin oval shape with a larger surface area that is more visible to the eye. The router that connects to your modem is styled just like a simple black router. The process of setting up the Orbi mesh network can be done with either the Orbi app or by plugging in a PC or Mac to directly into the router with either net. You will be asked to make a name for the network and a password for access. Once the network has been established you simply plugin and turn on your Orbi satellites and your router will find them. All in all, the process is completed in six steps. The dimensions and weight of each Satellite are as follows:

  • Dimensions: 6.7 x 3.1 x 8.89 inches
  • Weight: 1.96lb (890.5g) each

Specs

Wireless

  • 802.11ac/TTri-band WiFi technology
  • MU-MIMO
  • Beamforming
  • 4X4 (1.7Gbps) dedicated backhaul
  • 6 high-performance antennas

Ports

  • Router – 1 WAN & 3LAN
  • Satellite – 4 WAN
  • USB 2.0, power

Memory

  • 512 MB RAM
  • 4 GB flash

Processor

  • Quad-core ARM 710MHz

Power

  • 15 W power adaptor

Orbi App

The Orbi app is a point of control of your mesh network beyond just setting up your devices. From the app, you can manage your routers and other devices, view the status of your Orbi devices and enforce parental controls with a program called Circle that works with Disney. You can also run speed tests, pause the internet and view your usage over a time period. You may also create a WiFi network for guests, similar to the Google WiFi app.

orbi app speed test


Coverage & Performance

With a router and the two included Orbi Satellites, you can cover up to 5,000 square feet or 464.50 square meters. With an additional Orbi Satellite, you can reach 7,500 feet or 696.7 square meters. Orbi has some of the most on-point hardware components and the best performance out of the mesh networks Over a Local Network (LAN), you can expect to get around 550 Mbps speed. It also manages to maintain speeds relatively well when exceeding 100 feet. Accordingly, those gamers may want to consider this option if they need fast streaming speeds.

SALE
NETGEAR Orbi Ultra-Performance Whole Home Mesh WiFi System - WiFi router and two satellite extender with speeds up to 3Gbps over 7,500 sq. feet, AC3000 (RBK53)
  • Ultra-performance Mesh WiFi network blankets every inch of your home in super-fast and...
  • Eliminates WiFi dead zones and buffering 7,500 square feet of consistent coverage with...
  • Maintains speed even as more devices use your WiFi at the same time, thanks to patented...


eero Pro (2nd Gen)

eero
Amazon Eero Mesh

The Amazon eero Pro WiFi system is a mesh network that is comprised anywhere between two and three devices. There are a couple of offerings from eero that a slightly different. First you have the eero Home WiFi System that is an eero router with an additional one or two Beacons. The eero has ethernet ports whilst Beacons do not, hence one is Wifi generating whilst the other just relays the signal.  The second option is the eero Wifi Pro System, which is a pack of three eeros sold together, without Beacons. Inevitably, the Wifi Pro System will be that bit tighter and faster than the system with the Beacons, especially if the area is larger.


Design & Setup

The design of the eero Home WiFi system follows the standard that is seen with mesh wifi systems. The box is a white with a single light to show it’s operating with a small eero logo imprinted on it. Setup of the eero Wifi system is straightforward and mediated via the eero app, as per usual with mesh networks. Opening the app will run the setup wizard where some basic questions such as the layout of your home are asked. You then need to connect the eero (not a Beacon) to the modem and then you just need to add the Beacons to the network as instructed by the app. The weight an dimensions of the eero are as follows:

  • Dimensions: 4.8 x 1.2 x 4.8 inches
  • Weight: 240g

eero app


Specs

Wireless – eero

  • Tri-band WiFi radios, simultaneous 2.4GHz, 5.2GHz, and 5.8GHz wireless2x2 MU-MIMO, beamforming, IEEE 802.11a/b/g/n/ac
  • Thread 1.1 Border Router, Bluetooth® LE 4.2
  • WPA2 encryption, Family Profiles, DHCP, IPV6, NAT, VPN Passthrough, UPnP, Static IP, and Port Forwarding

Wireless – eero Beacon

  • Dual-band WiFi radios, simultaneous 2.4GHz and 5GHz wireless
  • 2×2 MU-MIMO, beamforming, IEEE 802.11a/b/g/n/ac
  • Thread 1.1 Border Router, Bluetooth® LE 4.2
  • WPA2 encryption, Family Profiles, DHCP, IPV6, NAT, VPN Passthrough, UPnP, Static IP, and Port Forwarding

Ports

  • Two auto-sensing Gigabit ports for WAN and/or LAN connectivity

Memory

  • 512 MB RAM
  • 4 GB flash storage

Processor

  • 700 MHz quad-core processor
  • 15 W power adaptor

Eero App

The eero app will allow you to set up your eero mesh network in under 10 minutes. It provides automatic updates to ensure ongoing security, features and performance maximization. The eero app also gives you suitable management over your network to allow you to:

  • View status & manage from anywhere
  • Share network with guests
  • Schedule & pause internet access
  • Block specific devices

There is a premium subscription option called eero Plus which includes some of the finer features you get with the other apps we have reviewed. This includes parental controls, advanced security and access to full-time experts to give a stronger service. Overall, Googles app is that little bit better designed and reliable, although the access to support and the stronger service is incredibly useful.


Coverage & Performance

eero is less specific with their promised coverage you can get with their mesh network. Rather than presenting an exact footage, they state that their eero Pro WiFi System (with 3 eeros) will cover a household with five or more bedrooms. Their most simple package with an eero and one Beacon covers a one to two-bedroom house. Their middle package can cover a three to four-bedroom house. Whilst this guide is not specific it at least offers some guidance. When it comes to delivering the end product, speedy and reliable wifi, eero is one of the strongest competitors. The eero mesh network is speedy at both shorter and longer distance, making it one of the best performing mesh wifi router. Over a Local Network (LAN), you can expect to get 600Mbps.

Amazon eero Pro mesh WiFi system (1 Pro + 2 Beacons)
  • Whole-home WiFi system - The Amazon eero Pro mesh WiFi system (1 eero Pro + 2 eero...
  • eero 2nd generation - With the most intelligent mesh WiFi technology and powerful...
  • WiFi extender - The eero Beacon is a full-fledged WiFi access point that simply plugs in...


Linksys Velop

velop
Linksys Velop

The Linksys Velop is our final mesh network in our comparison. As you have gathered, as wifi is a relatively one-dimensional product, everything from the design, features, and performance have been similar across the comparison. It won’t be a surprise the Linksys Velop follows the standards we have seen in mesh network systems. Just like the others, they are sold in flexible packages either as one, two or three. If there is one area where Linksys Velop sticks out, it is the ability to deliver the best speeds at a further distance.


Design & Setup

The Linksys Velop units again have a white style with a grey Linksys logo. These are rather differently styled in regards to shape and size compared to the other units. Rectangular, much taller and less compact, these units are bulkier than the other mesh routers we have overviewed above. They also a little bit heavier, although this shouldn’t weigh in as a problem. The setup is quick and comprised of a few stages that mirror the other brands. The first step is to setup the primary node or Parent by using the Linksys app instructions. Following that you simply connect the other nodes to the Parent node wirelessly.app. Dimensions and weight are as following:

  • Dimensions: 3.1 x 3.1 x 7.3 inches
  • Weight:630g

Specs

Wireless

  • Tri-Band AC2200 (867 + 867 + 400 Mbps)‡
  • with MU-MIMO and 256 QAM
  • Simultaneous Tri-Band (2.4Ghz + 5GHz + 5GHz)
  • Beamforming for 2.4 GHz and 5GHz bands
  • WPA2 personal

Ports

  • 2x WAN/LAN auto-sensing Gigabit Ethernet ports

Memory

  • 512 MB RAM
  • 4 GB flash storage

Processor

  • 716 MHz Quad Core

Antennas

  • 6 x internal

Linksys App

The Linksys app is a well produced and updated control panel for the mesh network. Standard features are included in a similar manner to the other apps available. It is also worth noting there is 24/7 customer care and a 3-year warranty. The features included for free are:

  • Remote access and management
  • View related statistics
  • Guest access
  • Prioritize devices
  • Parental controls

Coverage & Performance

A single Velop is suitable for a small living of around 2000 square feet and one or two bedrooms. Two Velops will have you covered in a 4,000 square feet area or three to four bedrooms. Finally, three Velops will cover up to a 6,000 square feet area and five or more bedrooms. The Linksys Velop has solid speeds, especially at the furthest range where it is the fastest. Over a Local Network (LAN), you can expect to get up to 550-500 Mbps. The Velops is very solid at the furthest distances, at 100 ft or over where it can maintain up to half its maximum speed.

SALE
Linksys Velop Mesh Router (Tri-Band Home Mesh WiFi System for Whole-Home WiFi Mesh Network) 3-PackAmazonUs/ White
  • Coming Soon – Apple HomeKit Compatibility
  • Ideal for large, 5+ bedroom multi-story homes (upto 6,000 sq.ft.)
  • Provides fast, reliable WiFi coverage for 4K streaming, gaming and more


Google WiFi vs Nest vs Orbi vs Eero vs Velop

The reality of all these mesh networks is that they contain very similar hardware and offer very similar specs. Your purchasing decision will most likely come down to any brand preference you have or budget.

Coverage

Although there is a small variation in the coverage of each of these mesh network systems, they will reach every corner of most homes. It is possible to add in more nodes with all brands at similar pricing.

Performance

Over a LAN network, these devices can output speeds far greater than what is currently required with a live internet connection from an ISP. All of these mesh network systems will handle commercially available internet speeds. The Google Nest WiFi is the fastest router across a range of differences.

Hardware

The hardware and tech specs contain all the same major pieces of kit in areas ranging from WiFi type to security.

App Control

This is another area where every brand ticks the boxes in regards to ease of use for setup, control, and monitoring. The top choice would have to be Google WiFi for its exceptional intuitive ease of use.

Customer Satisfaction

Although some users get smooth and quality experiences which fit the manufacturer’s promises, it is very important to consider customer satisfaction, This is one of the most insightful factors that should inform your decision. On the whole, these are all well-reviewed products compared to other areas of tech. Google WiFi and Amazon eero have the best customer satisfaction ratings with the most consistent results. Orbi has solid feedback too, although there used to be some firmware issues that have been resolved. The Velop appears to have the most pressing issues such as frequent disconnecting and splitting between 2.4 GHz and 5 GHz networks.

Final Word

Mesh routers are relatively one-directional yet complex devices. This is reflected by the similarity of the hardware used and the results produced by these top mesh network systems. The speeds, coverage and app are all at the same level of quality between the Google WiFi, Orbi, eero and Velop. When taking into account every feature, Google Nesy WiFi is the best overall mesh network. The tech giant magic touch in simplicity, quality, and premier software and hardware give the best all rounded system. Although other mesh routers have faster maximum speeds, this is unlikely to make a difference when using typical ISP speeds. Coverage among all brands is equal as the addition of more nodes will eliminate any performance issues. Google WiFi also has the easiest use and cleanest app.

FAQ

In this section, we will answer the most common questions that people ask about Mesh WiFi networks. These are typically about there effectiveness and advantages and disadvantages compared to regular internet routers.

Is mesh WiFi better than a router?

Mesh WiFi systems are only better than regular routers if you want to cover a larger area in your home. In general, the highest spec routers are better than Mesh Wifi routers at a shorter distance.

Does mesh WiFi slow down?

Yes, as the range extends further the mesh router signal will be poorer. That said, it will still be high enough performance for most tasks.

Is mesh WiFi better than an extender?

Mesh WiFi systems are rebroadcasted a signal more powerfully than an extender and there will be a stronger signal at the further distances.

What are the disadvantages of a mesh network?

They are quite expensive pieces of a kit and the routers aren’t as good at a shorte distance compared to the best regular routers.

Is a mesh WiFi network worth it?

If you wish to cover a large area in your home with a WiFi signal then they are a no brainer as regular extenders are not as powerful. A regular routers signal can not reach as far either.

FAQ: Google WiFi vs Orbi vs Velop

These questions are more tailored to answer questions specific to this comparison of the brands eero, Google WiFi, Orbi and Velop.

What is the best mesh WiFi system?

We believe that the Amazon eero Pro mesh WiFi system is the best out of the bunch due to its specs and performance. Being now owned by Amazon, the mesh system will only go fro strength to strength in the future.

What is better eero or Orbi?

As we believe that eero is the best mesh Wifi you can get, we also think it is by definition better than Orbi. In terms of supports, software, reliability and performance (speed) it beats Orbi.

How good is eero?

eero is the best mesh wifi network in our opinion, the top choice to go for currently.

Is eero a true mesh network?

Yes, eero is a true mesh network just like some of these models. It is a true tri-band system which basically means it uses a dedicated band for communication between devices.

Is ero the best mesh Wifi?

Yes, we believe so thanks to most importantly having the best performance, speed and reliability to name a few positives.

Which is better Orbi or Velop?

Velop is better for speeds at the furthest distances and Orbi is better for speeds at a shorter to medium distances. Orbi is the better bet for gaming provided you aren’t right at the edge of the coverage,

Is Orbi a true mesh network?

No, Netgear’s Orbi is technically slightly different from a true mesh network like Google WiFi and eero Pro. There is a main router with accompanying satellites, rather than consisting of three equally relevant routers that produce a signal.

Is Google mesh WiFi Tri-Band?

Nope, Google WiFi uses a simultaneous dual-band WiFi signal rather than a Tri-ban WiFi signal like that found in the other three models here.

is Orbi or Google WiFi better?

We believe that these two are very equally matched, although we prefer Google WiFi as the software is sublime and the customer support is solid.

 

Rupert Pople

Rupert is the founder of this website and a smart home tech enthusiast fascinated by the power of connected devices. Within his Business Management (BSc) degree at the University of Nottingham, he studied the technological impact of the Internet of Things.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button
Close